Pizza restaurants

Pizza Plus - 224 1st St

4.0 278 reviews 09:00 AM - 09:00 PM 224 1st St, Ault, CO 80610, United States

Discover this place

Pizza Plus is a pizza restaurant located at 224 1st St in Ault, Colorado. The establishment offers a variety of pizza styles, featuring options such as braided crusts that balance a thin, sturdy base with a soft, chewy interior and a crusty exterior. The menu includes classic offerings like calzones and Stromboli, alongside specialty items such as pizza rolls and wings. The use of homemade ingredients, particularly in their sausage, highlights a focus on fresh and flavorful components. The setting caters to both local diners and visitors passing through, providing a straightforward and welcoming atmosphere. Pizza Plus combines traditional pizza craftsmanship with a menu that appeals to different tastes, making it a notable spot within the local dining scene in Northeastern Colorado.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights

Serves local specialty

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Counter service
Dessert
Seating

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Quiet

Crowd

Groups

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Pizza Plus - 224 1st St before visiting.

Reviews for Pizza Plus - 224 1st St

4.0

278 reviews

100%

21%

13%

10%

21%

Review highlights

Based on 278 reviews

Pizza Plus in Ault, CO consistently receives positive feedback for its high-quality, flavorful pizzas characterized by well-balanced crusts that are both soft and crisp. Customers frequently highlight the homemade sausage and generous toppings, as well as the variety available on the menu. The service is noted for its attentiveness and responsiveness, with staff willing to quickly address any order inaccuracies. Many reviewers appreciate the freshness and hot delivery of the food, contributing to a satisfying dining experience. Additionally, the welcoming and friendly atmosphere of the restaurant encourages repeat visits, even from patrons traveling from nearby areas. Overall, Pizza Plus is praised for combining great food quality with reliable service, making it a favored choice for both locals and visitors passing through the area.

Dana Wagner

Aug 21, 2025

First time ordering here on a recommendation. This was a great pie!! We ordered the braided crust. It was soft and chewy on the inside and and nice crusty exterior. The base of the crust was thin and held up really well. We will definitely try again and explore more of the menu.

Christine Antikainen

Aug 07, 2025

Amazing pizza, this was our first time having it. We live in Hudson and will definitely be getting pizza from here again.

Christopher Lloyd

Jul 26, 2025

Ordered several kinds of pizza, Stromboli, and pizza rolls. Everything was amazing. It was delivered and they forgot a few things and didn’t hesitate to come deliver what was clearly accidentally forgotten. Great food and service!

Brian S

Jul 25, 2025

I really enjoy the pizza from here. Their sausage is home made and is awesome. I drive from fort collins area to get pizza here. The sauce is good, grate crust. Healthy amount of toppings. Nice people running it. Dont miss out on this pie. It's fantastic!

Jimmy McCants

Jun 12, 2025

This place is great, truck driver just passing through. Glad I stopped for lunch pizza and wings, hot and fresh.

Paula Cardona

May 20, 2025

We have passed by many times, decided to stop in and finally try some pizza! Fantastic pizza; nice crunchy crust that was soft on the inside, plenty of pepperoni and cheese and a sauce that had just the right amount of flavor. Staff were friendly and helpful with suggestions. Will absolutely come back next time in the area.